How to Work Out What ‘Drives’ Your Dog

Ever wondered, “What on earth is going on inside that adorable little head?” when looking at your pup? (When they’re undoubtedly looking back at you with that curious head tilt.) Whilst we can’t (sadly) read their minds, we can understand a bit more about the drives, motivations and instinctual behaviours that influence their sometimes downright unusual actions. 

Understanding what motivates your dog is essential for effective training and a harmonious relationship between pup and pet parent. In the world of canine behaviour, the term ‘drive’ is often used to describe the intensity of an instinct displayed by a dog. We delve into the intricacies of what drives your dog, exploring the different motivations that influence your pup’s behaviour and provide insights from experts to help you decode and work with your furry friend’s instincts.

What is a drive?

First and foremost, what is a dog’s drive? Evangelos Diamantakos, a clinical animal behaviourist and senior lecturer at Hartpury University, clarifies that ‘drive’ is a term used to measure the intensity of instincts displayed by a dog. These instincts fall under three primary categories – self-preservation, social and sexual (reproduction) – and manifest in a variety of behaviours, including eating, playing, hunting and exploring.

Related article

Puppy Training 101: How to Train a Puppy

You and your cute classmate have lots to learn

“We generally use the term ‘drive’ when assessing the level of an instinct exhibited by a dog,” says Evangelos. “For instance, we often say that a dog has a high prey drive when describing its keen interest in chasing a moving object, such as a ball. 

“Thus, the term ‘drive’ is commonly associated with the intensity of an instinct displayed by a dog. In our efforts to characterise the level of a drive, we use adjectives such as high, medium and low (eg, very high defence drive, or medium-low fight drive).”

Dr Katie Friel-Russell, a veterinary behaviourist and head trainer at Positive Pet Training, adds, “When we talk about drives for training, we can mean the things that reinforce their behaviour. What makes them more likely to do what they’re doing, or what would they choose to do if they could pick.”

What types of ‘drives’, or motivations, are there?

Common drives include food and play – often split into chasing, tug or retrieving – which, Dr Friel-Russell explains, emphasises the role of the predatory motor pattern in understanding these drives. This pattern sequence includes stalking, chasing, biting, killing, holding or carrying, and eventually eating. Different dogs may focus more on specific steps in this process, resulting in variations in their motivations to reinforce certain behaviours.

Related article

Your Dog’s Food Aggression Isn’t Cute – Here’s How You Can Work On It

No longer associate feeding time with growling time

Dogs are motivated by the need to exhibit instinctual behaviour. Under the three basic instincts (self-preservation, social and reproduction), “We can observe that dogs exhibit a wide variety of sub-instincts, such as eating, playing, fighting, retrieving, hunting, exploring, packing, defending, competing, protecting, fearing, ‘flight’ (running away), possessing and evaluating situations, etc,” says Evangelos.

How do you work out what drive your dog has?

Understanding your dog’s drives is essential for effective training. You probably already have a good idea of what your dog likes and which aspects of the predatory sequence are most important to them (hello Labrador scoffing down anything in sight), but it‘s not always as straightforward as you might think. 

Evangelos recommends assessing a puppy’s responses to food presentation and moving objects at an early stage (around four weeks) to determine the levels of the ‘eat drive’ and ‘prey drive’. “Explore how the puppy responds to food presentation and moving objects,” he explains. “The first aims to assess the level of the instinct to eat (eat drive), and the second aims to assess the level of the drive to chase a moving object (prey drive).” 

Related article

Some Like It Rough: Playing vs Fighting

Two animal behaviour experts agree that it’s usually play fighting. Here’s how you can tell

“There are lots of breed dispositions where certain breeds have been selected to focus on one or more areas,” adds Dr Friel-Russell. “For example, Collies and herding breeds on the chase, and Labradors on the hold and, more importantly, the consume aspects.”

“But we also know that we get plenty of variation within a breed as well as between breeds,” she adds, suggesting observing your pup on walks and offering games that target different aspects of the predatory sequence to help identify their preferences. Monitoring your dog’s excitement and experimenting with various treats and toys can provide insights into their preferences.

How can you work out what drives dogs that don’t seem like they have any drive?

For dogs that appear to lack motivation, in particular nervous or rescue dogs, Evangelos advises patience. These dogs may be solely focused on survival aspects due to fear, discomfort or previous experiences, and understanding their background is vital. Patience, timing and a tailored approach respecting the dog’s pace are key.

Dr Friel-Russell adds that even the most withdrawn or injured dogs need to eat, making food a valuable tool to work with them. 

“Often scared dogs or dogs in pain are solely focussed on the survival aspect of the drive, says Dr Friel-Russell. “This means they can’t show preference for other things so easily as they are too distracted. But even the most shut down animals need to eat, so you can always use their food to work with them and find the foods they enjoy the most to enrich their life in the meantime.”

Related article

How to Help an Anxious Dog Conquer Their Fears

Six animal behaviourists share pro tips for boosting the confidence of a fearful dog

Can you ‘instil’ a drive? 

While some aspects of the predatory sequence can be encouraged, the innate drives a dog is born with remain fundamental. Motivations in dogs are a combination of inherited (genetic) and acquired (learnt) characteristics, and whilst there is definitely the potential to increase the intensity of instinctive behaviour, as well as experiment with different motivations, Dr Friel-Russell notes that innate drives persist, making it challenging to completely alter them.

“You can try to encourage different aspects of the predatory sequence in your dog and many dogs will learn to enjoy other aspects and this gives you another string to your bow to use when training with your dog,” she explains. “But those innate drives your dog was born with are likely to persist and be the most important to them throughout their lives.”

Imprinting, where a puppy mimics the behaviour of an older dog, is a powerful way to instil a certain behaviour, says Evangelos, but carefully planning the training process, using positive reinforcement and understanding the dog’s preferences is key.

Related article

Top 10 Easiest Dogs to Train

Spoiler: it’s not about the breed. But these pups are pretty brainy

How does training differ for each drive? 

Understanding your dog better in any way allows for a more personalised training plan, but tailoring your training plan based on a dog’s drives can also enhance its effectiveness. Using high-value reinforcers based on your pup’s motivations and adjusting the difficulty level of training based on a dog's ability to cope with distractions in relation to their drives is also crucial.

“Depending on your dog’s drives it can influence what you use to reinforce behaviours for your dog,” says Dr Friel-Russell. “Using higher value reinforcers, or rewards, can help your dog learn faster. A Labrador is going to find it much harder waiting when there are treats on the floor, compared to a Collie waiting while a ball is thrown, or a Terrier waiting for a chase. By understanding their drives you can incorporate it and personalise their training plan.” 

Can you pull back on a drive?

Dr Friel-Russell suggests managing, not reducing, a dog’s drive to ensure appropriate outlets. Attempting to restrict access to a specific drive may increase its value, making dogs more likely to exhibit that drive in undesirable situations. Instead, she recommends providing opportunities for dogs to express their normal behaviours while incorporating self-control training.

This approach helps dogs manage their behaviour in situations where their drives may be triggered. For example, allowing a dog chasing opportunities and teaching a stop cue during play can lead to better behaviour management in situations where the instinct may pose a challenge, such as walking near livestock. 

Related article

How To Stop a Dog From Pulling on the Lead

Dog trainer Karen B London promises you’re not doomed to be pulled down the street forever

Understanding your dog’s drives is a journey, but by decoding their instincts and motivations, and appreciating the unique combination of genetic and learnt characteristics, pet parents can create a motivating environment that fosters positive behaviour and a strong bond between you and your four-legged friend.